Saturday 30 January 2016

PRECAUSTION QUESTIONS  BEFORE PURCHASE PROPERTY IN INDIA

Q 1.  How ownership of immovable property is acquired by a person? 
Ans.   A person may acquire immovable property in any of the following way
(i) By inheritance of ancestral property.
(ii) Through will.
(iii) Acquisition by oneself such as purchase etc.
(iv) Through gift, trust, settlement deeds.
(v) Grant, sanad / Inam by the Government
Through decree of Court.
There are two ways of acquisition:
 
1.By act of parties.
 
Example: Purchase, gift etc.
 
2. By operation of law
 
Example: Inheritance, decree of Court etc. (for details please see Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (Central Act))
Top

Q 2.  Is it necessary to register in Office of the Sub Registrar to get khata transferred in respect of property acquired by inheritance?
 
Ans.   Not necessary. After the death of owner of a property his heirs, such as wife, children i.e. male and female, married or unmarried may get the Khata transferred on production of death certificate of the owner with details of property held by him to the following officers.
 
If property is an agricultural land - Tahasildar (See Sec.128 of Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964) Offices of Corporation, Municipality, Panchayat or City survey if such office exists.
Top
Q 3 . Which are the documents requires to be compulsorily registered? 
Ans .  1. Gift deed of immovable property.
2. Other non-testamentary instruments, which purport or Operate to create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish whether in the present or in future, any right, title or interest, whether vested or contingent, of the value of one hundred rupees and upwards, to or in immovable property;
 
3. Non testamentary instruments which acknowledge the receipt or payment of any consideration on account of the creation, declaration, assignment, limitation or extension of any such right, title or interest;
4. Leases of immovable property from year or for any term exceeding one year, or reserving a yearly rent;
5. Non testamentary instruments transferring or assigning any decree or order of a court or any award when such decree or order or award purports or operates to create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish whether in the present or in future, any right, title or interest, whether vested or contingent, of the value of one hundred rupees and upwards, to or in immovable property;
6. The documents containing contracts to transfer for consideration, any immovable property for the purpose of section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 shall be registered if they have been executed on or after the commencement of the Registration and Other Related Laws (Amendment) Act, 2000 and if such documents are not registered on or after such commencement, then, they shall have no effect for the purposes of the said section 53A
Top

Q 4 .
 How to effect partition of .property? 
Ans.   a. If all the parties have share (common right) in the property partition can be effected. If partition is effected through an instrument such instrument must be compulsorily registered.
 
b. Oral partition affected through memorandum submitted to the concerned authorities need not be registered.
 
c. Stamp duty has to be paid in respect any kind of partition whether it is to be compulsorily registered or not.
 
d. Parties to the partition may agree to effect partition of unequal shares. 
 
Top
Q 5.  When there are two or more heirs, can one or two be made full owners by others taking money in lieu of their share?  
Ans .  a) Yes. Any of the co-owners can individually or collectively release his / their right in favour of one or more collectively as the case may be and make him / them full owner. This kind of release can be with or without payment of money. This document is called Release.
 
b) Release can be made not only in case of inherited property but also in case of joint purchase/acquisition.
 
Top

Q 6.  What is a will?
 
Ans.   A testamentary document by which a person bequeaths his property to be effective on his death is a will. The property will devolve on the person in whose favour it is bequeathed after death of testator.
Top 
Q 7 . Who can execute a will? 
Ans .  a) Any person above the age of 18 years and mentally sound may execute will, but will caused by fraud or coercion or by importunately will not be valid. Therefore a will must be executed voluntarily.
 
b) Parents or guardians cannot execute will on behalf of minors or lunatics.
 
c) Attestation by minimum two witnesses is necessary.
 
d) Scribe (deed writer / advocate) cannot be called witness. Two independent attesting witnesses other than the scribe or necessary.
e) Beneficiary under a will should not sign as attesting witness.
In order to avoid disputes in implementation of a will, description of property and the beneficiaries should be clearly be written without giving room for any doubt.
 
Top

Q 8.  Is it compulsory to register a will?
 
Ans .  It is not compulsory to register. Executants may register at his option. It is better to register the will. If original is lost a certified copy can be obtained from Sub-Registrar Office.
 
Top
Q 9 . Where can the will be registered? 
Ans.   It can be registered in any office of the Sub Registrar in India 
 
Top
Q 10  Is there any time limit to register a will? 
Ans .  There is no such time limit
 
Top
Q 11.  Can a will be cancelled?  
Ans.   The testator can cancel his will at anytime during his lifetime. Such cancellation deed requires a Stamp duty of Rs.100-00
 
Top
Q 12  Can a registered will be rectified or changed? 
Ans   If executant of a will wishes to rectify, add to will may do so during his lifetime. This is called codicil. This document does not require stamp duty.
Top
Q 13.  Can a will be registered even after death of testator? 
Ans.   Yes, claiming party under the will have to produce will, records relating to the death of the testator, witness and the scribe before the Sub Registrar. If Sub Registrar is satisfied about the truth and genuineness of the execution of the will, he will register.
Top
Q 14.  What is the Stamp duty and Registration fee to register a will? 
Ans .  There is no Stamp duty on will deed. For registration of will during the life time of the testator Rs.200-00 Registration fee prescribed. To register the will after the death of the testator Registration fee of Rs.200-00 and enquiry fee of Rs.250-00 is prescribed.
Top
Q 15 . Is the certified copy of a registered will available to any body? 
Ans .  A certified copy of a registered will is available to the testator only during his lifetime. After his death anybody can obtain after producing proof of death of testator.
Top 
Q 16 . How to keep contents of a will confidential?  
Ans.   Will can be deposited in a sealed cover in office of the District Registrar. A fee of Rs.1000-00 prescribed to deposit will in a sealed cover. Depositor or authorized person (executor) can withdraw the sealed cover containing a will, if desires to do so. A Registration of Rs.200-00 prescribed.
Top
Q 17.  What is the procedure to obtain the sealed cover containing a will after the death of the depositor? 
Ans .  On making an application along with proof of the death of the depositor, District Registrar will open sealed cover in the presence of the applicant and it will be registered. Certified copy will be issued if desired. A fee of Rs.100-00 prescribed to open a sealed cover.
 
Top
Q 18 . What is the procedure for change of khata of the properties obtained through will? 
Ans.   After the death of the testator person claiming through the will have to apply to the concerned authorities as explained in question no.2 along with the copy of the will and death proof.
 
Top
Q 19.  What are the duties and liabilities of buyers and sellers while purchasing a property? 
Ans.   Following is the duties and liabilities of buyers and sellers
Before sale
liabilities of seller  Liabilities of purchaser 
 
To inform defects in the property  
 
To provide records of right  
 
To execute sale deed  Payment of consideration 
 
To pay of the liabilities on the property
Rights
 
Rights of seller  Rights of buyer 
 
To get rent and profits  Right of encumbrance on consideration already paid 
 
After completion of sale
 
Liabilities of seller  Liabilities of purchaser 
 
To hand over possession  Liability on accidental or loss to the property 
 
Information about right  
 
To hand over records of rights after receipt of consideration  Duty to pay taxes and liabilities after taking possession of property 
 
Rights of seller  Rights of buyer 
 
If consideration is due encumbrance on property of such dues  Incremental value/profit on property 
 
Though there are rights and duties the purchaser should carefully examine the following matters;
 
1) Original documents.
 
2) How did the seller acquire the property.
 
3) Encumbrance Certificate of the property for a minimum period of 15 years from Sub Registry Office to know if there are any encumbrances on the property to be purchased.
 
4) Verify from the concerned court if there are any litigations on the property to be purchased.
 
5) Verify if there are any litigations, objections in revenue, municipal offices about inheritance or any other matter.
 
6) If seller is a power of attorney holder, it should be verified from the principal and if such power of attorney is genuine and whether it is still in force.
 
7) It should be verified whether the transaction is opposed to public policy under Section 22A of the Registration Act, 1908. If so the document will not be registered.
 
8) If the Property is a granted land to the member of scheduled caste and scheduled tribe, it should be verified if the transaction is in contravention of the terms and conditions of grant and whether permission of the Government is obtained for transfer.
 
Top

Q 20 . What are the transactions opposed to public policy?
 
Ans   Government has declared the following as opposed to public policy under Section 22A of Registration Act, 1908 namely,-
(1) (a) Agreement to sell, sale, gift, exchange, mortgage, lease or assignment of land of which the occupancy right has been granted under Chapter III of the Karnataka Land Reforms Act, 1961 in contravention of the restrictions imposed under section 61 of the said act and the rules framed there under.
(b) Agreement to sell, sale, gift, exchange or otherwise of any land in excess of the ceiling limit specified in section 63 or 64 of the Karnataka Land Reforms Act, 1961 in contravention of section 74 of the said act and the rules framed there under.
(c) Agreement to sell, sale, lease, mortgage with possession or otherwise of any agricultural lands to a person or a family or a joint family who or which has an assured annual income of rupees Two lakhs and above from sources other than agriculture in contravention of section 79-A of the Karnataka Land Reforms Act, 1961 and the rules framed there under.
(d) Agreement to sell, sale, lease, mortgage with possession or otherwise of any agricultural land to an educational, religious, charitable institution society, trust, company, association, other body of individuals or a co-operative Society other than the co-operative farming society in contravention of section 79-B of the Karnataka Land Reforms Act, 1961 subject to the exceptions and exemptions provided under section 109 of the said act and the rules framed there under.
(e) Agreement to sell, sale, gift, lease, mortgage with possession or otherwise of any agricultural land granted under the Karnataka Land Grant Rules, 1969 subject to restrictions on sale, transfer, and specific use imposed there under as per the provisions of the said Rules.
(2) One cannot possess land as owner, tenant or as mortgagee with possession in excess of 10 units. If a family consists of more than five members, such family may hold two units per head not exceeding 20 units.
 
PART A
[See Section 2(A)(35-A)
Classification of Lands
A Class
Lands having facilities for assured irrigation from such Government Canals and Government Tanks as are capable of supplying water for growing two crops of paddy or one crop of sugarcane in a year.
B Class
(i) Lands having facilities for assured irrigation from such Government Canals and Government Tanks as are capable of supplying water for growing only one crop of paddy in a year.
(ii) Lands irrigated by such lift irrigation projects constructed and maintained by the State Government as are capable of supplying water for growing two crops of paddy or one crop of sugarcane in a year.
C Class
(i) Lands irrigated from any Government sources of irrigation, including lift irrigation projects constructed and maintained by Government other than those coming under A Class and B Class.
(ii) Lands on which paddy crop can be raised or areca crop is grown with the help of rain water.
(iii) Lands irrigated by lifting water from a river or Government Canal or Government tank where the pumping installation or other device for lifting water is provided and maintained by the land owner.
Notes
(1) Lands having facilities for irrigation from a Government Source where the system of water supply is suitable for growing only light irrigated crop namely, crops other than paddy and sugarcane shall come under this class.
(2) Lands growing irrigated garden crop will come under classes ‘A’, ‘B’ or ‘C’ as the case may be depending upon the source of irrigation and the system of water supply.
D Class
Lands classified as dry but not having any irrigation facilities from a Government source.
Note.- Lands growing paddy or garden crops not coming under A Class, B Class or C Class shall belong to this class.
PART B
Formula of determining equivalent extent of different classes
One Acre of A Class land having soil classification value above 8 annas = 1.3 acres of A Class land having soil classification value below 8 annas = 1.5 acres of B Class land having soil classification value above 8 annas = 2.0 acres of B Class land having soil classification value below 8 annas = 2.5 acres of C class land having soil classification value above 8 annas = 3.0 acres of C class land having soil classification value below 8 annas = 5.4 acres of D Class land.
Top

Q 21.  Is it necessary to obtain permission for transfer of agricultural land granted under Land Grant Rules or granted occupancy right under Land Reforms Act even after lapse of condition for transfer? 
 
Ans.   Yes. Application should be submitted to Tahasildar and acknowledgement is obtained. If permission is not granted within 15 days after getting acknowledgement, document can be registered as if permission is granted.
 
Top
Q 22 . What are other restrictions to purchase agricultural land? 
Ans .  Lands granted to persons belonging to scheduled caste or scheduled tribe cannot be transferred or purchased without prior permission of the Government. This restriction does not apply to mortgagee in favour of co-operative or scheduled banks and partition among family members
2. Social or Industrial organizations can purchase with the permission of the Government (Refer Sec.109 of Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964). 
 
Top
Q 23.  How to get transfer of immovable property?  
Ans .  a. As explained under Question 3, if value of property under sale, exchange, lease, and mortgage is Rs.100 or more, deed relating to such transaction must be compulsorily registered (Sec.17 of Registration Act 1908).
 
b. Gift deed, must be registered irrespective of the value of the property.
 
c. After the deed is registered `J' slip is sent to Tahasildar in case of agricultural land and city survey office, in case of city non-agricultural property of properties are under city survey. The purchaser should get confirmed whether khatha is transferred through `J' slip.
 
In areas where there is not city survey is not in operation, one has to apply along with copy of the deed to the concerned Corporation/ Municipal/panchyat office to effect transfer of khatha.
Top

Q 24 . What is the purpose of Registration? 
 
Ans.   (a) By Registration of transaction of immovable property will become permanent public record. This is a notice to the general public. Those getting transfer of property should verify whether such property has been previously encumbered.
 
(b) According to Transfer of Property Act right, title or interest can be acquired only if the deed is registered.
 
Top

Q 25 . What are the effects of non-registration?
 
Ans  . If a deed of transfer, which is compulsorily registrable, is not registered it will not be admissible in evidence (Sec.49 of Registration Act 1908)
 
Top
Q 26.  Is there time limit to present a document for registration after it is executed (signed)? 
Ans  . a. Document may be presented for registration within four months from the date of execution (signature).
 
b. If a document is executed out of India, the period of four months will be counted from the date of its receipt in India.
 
c. After four months document may be presented within another four months with penalty subject to maximum of ten times the registration fees if the District Registrar grants permission. But document may be presented before Sub Registrar within eight months. Thereafter it cannot be accepted for registration. (For details please see Rule 52 of Karnataka Registration Rules, 1965).
 
Top

Q 27.  What is the day today timing for acceptance of deeds for registration in Sub Registry offices?
 
Ans.   Generally deeds are accepted during working hours. Sub Registrar may stop accepting two hours before closing time if he has sufficient work to attend in respect of deeds already received for registration.
 
Provided deeds may be accepted in emergency cases on payment of extra fee of Rs.200 one hour before sunrise and one hour after sunset and on holidays.
Top
Q28.  Can the document presented for registration be withdrawn?  
Ans .  Registering officer may permit withdrawal of the document before completion of registration on written request by the party who presented the document. Fifty percent of the registration fee is refundable. Likewise Stamp duty is also refundable subject to deductions. (Please see question No.19 on stamp duty F.A.Q.)
 
Top
Q 29 . Who should be present at the time of registration? 
Ans .  A deed may be presented for registration either by claiming or executing party but the executant / executants must be present to admit execution (signing) of the deed (Please see Sec.32 of Registration Act 1908).
 
Top
Q 30.  What is the course, if executing party refuses to appear in Registry Office to admit execution? 
Ans  . a. In such circumstances, registering office will issue notice/ summons to the Executant. If the party does not turn up registering officer will refuse registration.
 
b. Application may be made to the District Registrar on such refusal to the District Registrar who will hold enquiry and decide the case. Rs.250 should be paid for such application.
 
c. One may submit appeal to the Civil Court if District Registrar also refuses to order for registration (For details please see Sec.73, 74, 75, 76 & 77 of Registration Act 1908).
Top

Q 31.  Who can sign as witness to a document? 
 
Ans .  Any person, above 18 years of age and not a party to the document may sign as witness.
Top 
Q 32.  What is meant by Identifying witness of person presenting/executing a document?  
Ans .  In order to identify genuineness of the persons executing the document, signature of identifying witness are obtained. Without such witness, registering officer may refuse registration.
Top
Q 33 . Who is authorise to write a deed? 
Ans .  Deed may be personally written by the executant or may be drafted by a licensed deed writer or advocate.
Top
Q 34 . Is it necessary to register immovable property by Government as inam or granted on darkhast?  
Ans .  They are exempted from registration. Khatha is effected on the basis of orders of Government (see Sec.90 of Registration Act 1908).
Top 
Q 35.  Are there any kind of documents registered without personal appearances of the parties for registration?  
Ans  . 1. Mortgage deed executed under Improvement Loans etc.
 
2. Certificate of sale issued by revenue court.
3. Documents executed by farmers in favour of primary co-operative land development bank to obtain loan and loan bonds executed by farmers in favour of banks under Karnataka Agricultural Credit Co-operations and Miscellaneous Provisions Act 1975 are sent under Sec.89 of the Registration Act and they are filed.
Top
Q 36I.s it necessary to register deed relating to transfer or assignment of decree relating to immovable property?  
Ans .  If value of the property involved in decree is Rs.100 or more and creates, declares, transfer, limit or extinguish right it should be compulsorily registered (See Sec.17 (e) of Registration Act).
Top 
Q 37.  Explain the registration of adoption deed?  
Ans.   Adoption deed maybe executed and registered like any other deed. Stamp duty Rs.45 and registration fee Rs.200 are leviable on it.
Top 
Q 38.  Explain the Power of Attorney? 
Ans .  There are two kinds of Power of Attorney.
 
1. General Power of Attorney (GPA)
 
2. Special Power of Attorney (SPA)
 
a) General Power of Attorney is executed by a person in favour of another to act on behalf of him generally. It may include management of property, Court matter/litigations, sale of mortgage of property or any other act.
 
b) Special Power of Attorney is executed to do a particular act. Power of Attorney holder is answerable to the principal and liable to give accounts to him. 
 
Top
Q 39.  Does property get transferred by getting a General Power of Attorney from the person selling it? Can the agent become owner of property? 
Ans .  No. It is wrong to say that ownership is transferred by getting General Power of Attorney. Persons purchasing property must get the sale deed registered. This principle applies to other kinds of transactions also. 
 
Top
Q 40.  Who can execute Power of Attorney? 
Ans .  A person who has attained majority may execute power of attorney in favour of another person who has attained majority including family members like brother, sister, father and mother to act on his behalf. If a power of attorney is executed to sell property in favour of relatives other than those mentioned above, 2 percent stamp duty shall be paid on market value of such property. If a power of attorney is executed in favour of developers, Builders of apartment, 4 percent stamp duty shall be paid on market value of such property. (see article 5(f) & 41(a), 41(ea), Schedule to Karnataka Stamp Act 1957).
 
Top

Q 41.  When would a General Power of Attorney gets cancelled? 
 
Ans.   a. GPA automatically gets cancelled on the death of Executant.
 
b. Principal (Executant) may cancel it any time.
Top
Q 42  .What does Irrevocable Power of Attorney mean? 
Ans.   If the Power of attorney is executed for consideration in respect of property it cannot be unilaterally revoked, prejudicial to the interest of the agent (See Sec.202 of Indian Contract Act, 1872).
Top
Q 43.  What is the meaning of a Special Power of Attorney? 
Ans .  (a) Power of Attorney executed by a person in favour of another to act on his behalf for specific purpose is called Special Power of Attorney.
 
(b) If a person is unable to go over to registry office to present a document executed in his favour or to admit execution of document executed (signed) by him, such power of attorney shall be authenticated or attested by a Sub Registrar. Otherwise they are not acceptable for the purpose of registration.
Top

Q 44 .
 Is it compulsory to register power of attorney attested in India by Magistrate or notary?  
Ans .  They need not be registered. But General Power of Attorney containing authority to present or admit execution of a document executed by the principle is not acceptable for such presentation or admission of execution unless they are attested or authenticated by a Sub Registrar.
Top
Q 45 . Is it compulsory to register General Power of Attorney executed by persons residing out of India and attested by officers of Consulate office of India in that country?  
Ans.   It is not necessary to register. But Stamp duty as per Article 41 shall be paid within 3 months from the date of receipt of the power of attorney in India.
Top
Q 46.  Is it compulsory to get a Power of Attorney attested by a Sub Registrar if it has already been attested by Magistrate or Notary, under which documents are signed by the agent? 
Ans .  Not necessary
 
Top
Q 47.  What is meant by Encumbrance Certificate? 
Ans .  Encumbrance Certificate is a record showing registered transactions pertaining to a property. If mortgage, sale or any other deeds in respect of a property are registered, encumbrance certificate is issued Form No.15.
Click here to download Prescribed application form no.22 to obtain Encumbrance Certificate.
Top
Q 48.  What is meant by a Nil Encumbrance Certificate? 
Ans .  If no deeds of transactions are registered in respect of a property nil encumbrance certificate is issued in Form No.16. If Certificate is issued in this form, it means that there are no registered transactions / liabilities on the property for a given period of time unregistered transactions are not included in this certificate.
Click here to download Prescribed application form no.22 to obtain Encumbrance Certificate.
Top

Q 49 .
 What is the fee for Encumbrance Certificate? 
Ans  .
 a. Application fee Rs.5 
b. Rs.30 for search of first year and Rs.10 for every subsequent year. Example: To obtain Encumbrance Certificate for 13 years. Application fee Rs.5-00 plus first year Rs.30-00 plus 12 years Rs.120-00 and total Rs.155-00.
Top
Q 50 . How to obtain Certified Copy of registered document? 
Ans .  1. Any person may obtain certified copy of registered document relating to immovable property.
 
2. Certified copy of registered will may be obtained only by the testator only during his lifetime. Any person may get copy of a will after the death of the testator on production of death certificate.
 
3. Copies of registered deed of GPA and other documents relating to movables may be obtained by executant / claimant or agent, representative of such person only.
 
Stamp paper of Rs.10 is required to be produced along with the application and copying fee of Rs.3 for every page of Xerox copy or Rs.5 for every 100 words or part thereof is to be paid.
 
Points to be noted by registering public for registration of a document
No. Do's Don'ts
 
1  Meet registering officer directly for your work  Do not depend on middlemen for your work  
2  Pay the fees required to be paid directly to the registering officer and obtain receipts  Do not pay money to the middlemen. 
 
3  Market value of each area is published. Pay stamp duty as per market value  Purchase stamp papers from licensed stamp vendors only. Beware of fake stamp papers 
 
4  Verify whether date of delivery of the registered deed is written on the receipt. Keep the receipt securely with you only  Don't handover receipt to middlemen. 
 
5  Get information records to be produced for registration in the registry office  Don't go for registration without necessary records. 
 
6  Fee for drafting/writing documents are prescribed. Pay accordingly and obtain receipts for it  Don't pay without receipt. Do not pay fee for drafting and registration together if demanded. Pay Registration fee directly in the office.
 
7  Contact higher authorities for any doubts and complaints.  Do not conceal your feelings about the officer or staff. Inform the higher authorities. 
 
8  Obtain registered deeds personally or through registered post.  Do not depend on middlemen for return of document after registration. 
 
9  Note true market value of property  Under valuation is an offence.
Top

Q 51 .
 Where can I register my immovable property ? 
Ans .  Documents pertaining to immovable property shall be registered in the Sub-Registrar office in whose jurisdiction the property is situated
 
Or If you have any problem with the Sub-Registrar's office please approach the District Registrar of your district.In Bangalore Urban district still if you have problem in registration you can visit the Office of the Inspector General of Registration where your registration work pertaining to Bangalore Urban district will be attended.
Circular
Top
Source: www.karigr.org  



Friday 22 January 2016


APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE WITH REGARD TO THE REVENUE RECORDS



Revenue documents are the documents maintaining by the revenue authority either based on the information as to the possession of the property given either by the person in possession of the property, sub-registrar, court, or based on the enquiry by the revenue officer. The following revenue records are maintaining by the revenue authority;

1.           Records of Rights
2.          Records of Rights and Tenancy Certificate;    

Revenue documents are not substitution for the title deeds. It is only for the purpose of collection of land revenue.


Section 133 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act read as follows.
133. Presumption regarding entries in the records.—An entry in the Record of Rights and a certified entry in the Register of Mutations or in the patta book shall be presumed to be true until the contrary is proved or a new entry is lawfully substituted therefor.

The entries in the revenue records, particularly, the mutation, do not in law confer title on any one. There can be no quarrel on this proposition of law. But these entries are more than sufficient to show now the revenue authorities had in exercise of their public duties, recorded the fact that was available and how the properties in question were being enjoyed and by whom. The entry in the revenue records can be considered to ascertain the mode of acquisition of ownership of the person on the land and his possession on the property.  When entry found in the revenue records, but, not in actual possession of the property, the Plaintiff can not take advantage of the same. The entries in the RTC and mutation are rebuttable presumptions. When the entry by the public officer during his discharge of official duty, the presumption is that the entries are true and correct. The Defendant shall rebut the said presumption.

It is also well settled that the entries in the record of rights only raise a presumption that the person whose name is entered in the record of rights is in possession of the suit lands but the same can be rebutted by adduction of evidence-documentary or oral on record. Held by Division Bench of Supreme Court. (2008-MPJR-2-300 Mahant Ram Khilawan Das V/s State of M P).

Where there are conflicts as to two sets of entries, it is the later entry which must prevail. Where new entry is substituted for an old one it is the new entry which will take the place of the old one and will be entitled to the presumption of correctness until and unless it is established to be wrong or substituted by another entry (AIR 1963 SC 361 Raja Durga Singh of Solon V/s Tholu).

If there is entry of the name of the others for intervene period, it can not be considered as stray entry. The factum of partition recorded in the mutation or RTC, it is a good evidence of partition. If survey maps, map index and Hadbundi papers prepared after due enquiry, can be relied. If the revenue documents produced in the name of the person with the entry of the sale deed without producing the sale deed before the court, no presumption as to execution of the sale deed. 

The certified copies of the revenue records are the secondary evidence. The revenue records maintained in the officer of the revenue department are the primary evidences. The production of certified copies of the revenue documents are permissible under law.

In a decision reported in AIR 2008 SC 901 Gurunath Manohar Pavaskar Vs Nagesh Siddappa Navalgund, the Supreme Court held that “A revenue record is not a document of title. It merely raises a presumption in regard to possession. Presumption of possession and/or continuity thereof both forward and backward can also be raised under section 110 of the Indian Evidence Act.

In a decision reported in 1976 (3) SCC 642 in the case of Vishwa Vijay Bharati Vs Fakhrul Hassan, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that “it is true that the entries in the revenue record ought, generally, to be accepted at their face value and courts should not embark upon an appellate inquiry into their correctness. But the presumption of correctness can apply only to genuine, not forged or fraudulent, entries. The distinction may be fine but it is real. The distinction is that one cannot challenge the correctness of what the entry in the revenue record states but the entry is open to the attack that it was made fraudulently or surreptitiously. Fraud and forgery rob a document of all its legal effect and cannot found a claim to possessory title”.

In the decision reported in 1977 (2) KantLJ 126 in the case of Srikante Gowda Vs Land Reforms Tribunal, Thirthahalli, the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka held that “there is a statutory presumption that an entry in the Record of Rights is true until the contrary is proved or a new entry is lawfully substituted therefor. The burden of proving that the entry in the Record of Rights is not true is on the party alleging that such entry is not true”.

In the decision reported in 1978 KantLJ 119 in the case of Laxmi Shedthi Vs Udupi Taluk Land Tribunal, the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka held that “Sec.133 of the Land Revenue Act states that an entry in the Record of Rights shall be presumed to be true until the contrary is proved or a new entry is lawfully substituted therefor. The burden was clearly on the second respondent to show that the legal presumption arising under Sec. 133 of the Land Revenue Act should not be drawn”.

In the decision reported in ILR 1985 Kar 2121 in the case of State of Karnataka Vs Annegowda, the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka held that “Section 133 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964 provides that an entry in the Record of Rights and an entry in the Register of Mutations, shall be presumed to be true until the contrary is proved or a new entry is lawfully substituted thereof. When the defendants have not produced any evidence to doubt the correctness of the said entries in the Record of Rights, the Court has to raise a presumption about its correctness and the mere allegations that they arc not genuine are not sufficient to rebut that presumption”.

In the decision reported in 2007 (11) SCC 736 between Narain Prasad Aggarwal (Dead) by LRs. V/s State of M.P. the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that “Record of right is not a document of title. Entries made therein in terms of Section 35 of the Indian Evidence Act although are admissible as a relevant piece of evidence and although the same may also carry a presumption of correctness, but it is beyond any doubt or dispute that such a presumption is rebuttable”.

In a decision reported in 2007 (6) SCC 186 in the case of Suraj Bhan V/s Financial Commissioner, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that “It is well settled that an entry in Revenue Records does not confer title on a person whose name appears in Record of Rights. It is settled law that entries in the Revenue Records or Jamabandi have only 'fiscal purpose' i.e. payment of land-revenue, and no ownership is conferred on the basis of such entries. So far as title to the property is concerned, it can only be decided by a competent Civil Court (vide Jattu Ram v. Hakam Singh and Ors.)”.

The electricity bills, phone bills, postal letters or tax paid receipts are not document of proof of the possession. These documents can be considered along with other documents showing his possession.
  
Evidentiary value of the certified copy of the revenue records - “Under section 79 of the Indian Evidence Act a court is bound to draw the presumption that a certified copy of a document is genuine and also that the officer signed it in the official character which he claimed in the said document. But such a presumption is permissible only if the, certified copy is substantially in the form and purported to be executed in the manner provided by law in that behalf. If so, it follows that the court is not bound to draw the presumption in regard to its genuineness”. (AIR 1959 SC 960 – Bhinka V/s Charan Singh)
Sources: Judicial Exam/Acadamy Notes